Iran releases rebuttal footage of sailors playing chess

The Brits really should've quit while they were ahead . . .

Too late now.



Iranian television broadcast video footage Sunday showing a British navy crew playing chess and watching television during their nearly two-week captivity in Iran, saying the footage refutes the sailors' and marines' claims that they were mistreated.

Crew members told reporters two days ago after returning to Britain that they had been blindfolded, held in isolation, frightened and coerced into falsely saying that they had entered Iranian waters before they were seized.

Some of the video clips, briefly aired on Iran's state-run Arabic satellite TV channel Al-Alam, showed several of the eight sailors and seven marines dressed in track suits and playing chess and table tennis. Other clips showed crew members watching soccer on television and eating at a long table decorated with flowers. Crew members could be heard laughing and chatting.

A newscaster who spoke over the beginning of the footage said the video proved "the sailors had complete liberty during their detention, which contradicts what the sailors declared after they arrived in Britain."

On Friday, Lt. Felix Carman, who was in charge of the crew when it was captured March 23, said the sailors and marines were only allowed to socialize for the benefit of the Iranian media.

"We were kept in isolation until the last few nights, when we were allowed to get together for a few hours, in the full glare of the Iranian media," Carman said at a news conference. "But that was very much a setup, very much a stunt for Iranian propaganda."

The crew members also insisted that they were in Iraqi waters when they were seized.

Iran dismissed the sailors' news conference as propaganda.

Two days before their release, Tehran had pledged not to show more video of the captured crew.

So? And Lt. Carmen pledged not to change his story as soon as he was returned to the UK.

Obviously, that wasn't upheld. Why should Iranians keep their end of the bargain?

Besides, even if Iranians treated the sailors kindly merely as a publicity stunt - at least they treated them kindly!

I'd rather be pampered for Iranian tv - than be tortured for American, British, or israeli 'national security.'

The British Foreign Office did not immediately return a phone call seeking comment Sunday.

How could they?

Basically, the UK has strangulated themselves with this one - there's no way they can come out of it looking good.

____________________________________
Thanks, Susan for the Guardian link.

Thanks, Cherifa for the real video of Felix Carman's Famous Last Words.

Posted in

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

The rebuttal footage is hilarious! If I were in the British navy, I would pack my bags, go home and not appear for a few years until the world forgets the disgrace...lol!!! If the footage doesn't get to the US by tomorrow, I'm sending it to you too:) It is most enjoyable!

Cherifa Sirry | Mon, 2007-04-09 07:20

If the Iranians told them to be good actors for the camera or get tortured, then every single soldier in that film deserves an Oscar Academy Award. Hell, blow up Hollywood and pay those guys and girls to star in all upcoming movies!!

While agreeing to participate in the "war on terror" is completely despicable, you can't be too hard on these soldiers for lying. You know their pensions, jobs, livehood were semi-legally threatened if they didn't follow orders and say they were mistreated.

Sadly, but understandably, most people would choose a secure retirement over morals, truth, and justice.

PEACE AND SOLIDARITY

Embracing substance in a soundbite era www.panaceamedia.org

panaceamedia | Tue, 2007-04-10 10:40

The pussified Daily Show actually showed a clip of this video! I'm shocked!

Embracing substance in a soundbite era www.panaceamedia.org

panaceamedia | Tue, 2007-04-10 11:04

got a link to the clip?

---------------------------------------
"Money" has no value - people do.

qrswave | Tue, 2007-04-10 14:48

They didn't compare it to the way the American government treats its "captives", but at least they mentioned it I guess. (I usually just stick with Colbert, for one since Stewart doesn't seem to know the difference between Zionists and Jews)

http://www.comedycentral.com/motherload/index.jhtml?ml_video=84619

Embracing substance in a soundbite era www.panaceamedia.org

panaceamedia | Tue, 2007-04-10 20:33

unclesam wakeup

It ain't racism when it's the truth!

by Grim Reaper

US Gross National Debt

Just Foreign Policy Iraqi Death Estimator